WHEN RON came home from New Orleans, Claire didn’t get up from the couch. She didn’t clean up, shop, cook, change the sheets, put on lipstick, or try to make it better. She lay in her red bathrobe on the couch, sherry bottle right by her hand, she’d been sipping steadily all day long, eating cinnamon toast and leaving the crusts, listening to opera.
Hysterical loves and inevitable betrayals. The women all ended up stabbing themselves, drinking poison, bitten by snakes.
“For Christ’s sake, at least get dressed,” Ron said. “Astrid shouldn’t have to see this.”
I wished he wouldn’t use me as a reason. Why couldn’t he say, I’m worried about you, I love you, you need to see someone?
“Astrid, do I embarrass you?” Claire asked. If she were sober, she would never have put me on the spot like that.
“No,” I said. But it did, when they passed me back and forth like a side dish at dinner.
Ron said, “You embarrass me.”
“Now we’re getting somewhere. Tell me, Ron, have I always embarrassed you? Or is this a recent development?”
He pointed with that smooth clean finger. “Don’t.”
I wished she’d bite it, break it off, but instead she glanced down, finished her drink and put the sherry glass on the table, carefully, and nestled down under the mohair blanket. She was always cold now. “Did she go with you? The blond, what’s-her-bimbo, Cindy. Kimmie.”
“Oh this.” He turned away, starting picking things up, dirty Kleenexes, empty glasses, dishtowel, bowl. I didn’t help him. I sat on the couch with Claire, wishing he’d leave us alone.
fun along with the crap.”
Claire watched him with heavy-lidded eyes, red-rimmed from crying.
“She doesn’t embarrass you, though. It doesn’t embarrass you to be running around with her.”
He reached down to pick up her empty glass. “Blah, blah, blah.” Before I realized what was happening, she sprang to her feet and slapped him across the face. I was glad, she’d needed to do that for months.
It took all her strength just to slap him. I felt both sorry and disgusted.
“You promised,” he said. “If we got a child.”
“I can’t help it,” she said.
“I didn’t think so,” he said. “She really should go, then.”
Pleading? Confusion? I waited for her to defend me, something, but she didn’t respond.
“It isn’t working out,” he continued.
What struck me was not so much that he could talk about sending me back, like a dog you got from the pound when it dug up the yard and ruined the carpets.
“Maybe you’re the one who’s not working out,” she said, reaching for the sherry bottle as she said it. He knocked it from her hand. It went flying, I heard it hit and roll on the pine floor.
“I can’t stand your poses,” he said. “Who are you supposed to be now, the wounded matriarch? Christ, she takes care of you. That wasn’t the idea.”
He was lying. That was exactly the idea. He got me to take care of her, keep an eye on her, keep her company while he was away.
“You can’t take her away,” was all she said. “Where would she go?”
“She’ll have a place, I’m sure,” Ron said. “But look at you. You’re falling apart. Again. You promised, but here we are. And I’m supposed to drop everything and put you back together again. Well, I’m warning you, if I have to pick up the pieces again, you’re going to give up something too.” Still the reasonable voice. He was making it all her fault.
“You take everything away,” she sobbed. “You leave me with nothing.” He turned away from her, and now I could see his face, the disgust.
“God, you’re such a bad actress,” he said. “I’d almost forgotten.”
“Do you have to take everything? Do you have to have it all?”
I peeked out the door, she was back lying on the couch. She pulled the mohair blanket up over her head. I could hear her moaning.
I closed the door and sat on my bed, helpless. It was my mother all over again.
I was the one who worried, submitted to her rituals, calmed her fears, while he was off chasing poltergeists and Virgin Mary apparitions. How could he send me away now?
I didn’t think Claire could get any paler, but when she saw Ron with those bags, she turned powder white. She scrambled from the couch, the blanket fell to the floor. “Don’t go.” She grabbed onto his corduroy jacket. “You can’t leave me. I love you.”
“Work it out.”
I went back to my room and lay facedown on the bed. I couldn’t stand to watch her crawl after him, grabbing onto his legs, begging, staggering after him out the door, in her red Christmas bathrobe all falling open. I could hear her outside now, weeping, promising she’d be good, promising him everything. The slam of his car door, the engine starting up, the unwinding ascending note of the Alfa backing out as she continued to plead
Weakling, I thought. Traitor. She was in front of my door, but I didn’t answer. She would give me up for him, she would do anything to have him.
Just like before, my mother and Barry. “Please, Astrid,” she begged me through the door, but I wouldn’t listen. This sickness would never happen to me.
Finally she went to her room, closed the door, and I hated her for crawling after him and hated myself for my disgust, for knowing just how Ron felt. I lay there on my bed, hating all of us, listening to her cry, she’d done nothing but for a week. Twenty-seven names for tears.
I heard Leonard Cohen start up, asking if she heard her master sing. The circular repetition of an overwhelming question. I wanted to seal myself up, while I still had something of my own that I hadn’t given to Claire. I had to pull back or I would be torn away, like a scarf closed in a car door.
How I despised her weakness. Just like my mother said I would. It repelled me. I would have fought for her, but Claire couldn’t even stand up for herself. I couldn’t save us both. On my desk was the picture of me and the steelhead trout from summer. Ron had it framed. I looked so happy. I should have known it wouldn’t last. Nothing lasts. Didn’t I know that by now? Keep your bags packed, my mother said. And me with less than a year to go, with college dangling before me.
But then I remembered how Claire took me to Cal Arts to see if I wanted to apply there, even got me the application. How she made me take honors classes, helped me with the homework, drove me to the museum every Tuesday night. If I had a future at all, it was only because she gave it to me. But then I saw her crawling again, begging, and was repelled afresh.
Astrid help me. Astrid pick up the pieces. How could I? I was counting on her too much. I had to start facing that.
I drew until it got dark, then turned on the light and spun the pyramid that hung over my desk, the ridiculous pyramid my mother had sold Claire on. When I closed the Kandinsky book, I couldn’t help noticing the inscription. To Astrid, with all my love, Claire.
It went through me like a current, shorting out my childish resentment.
If I had anything good, it was only because of Claire. If I could think of myself as worthwhile for a second, it was because Claire made me think so.
If I could contemplate a future at all, it was because she believed there was one. Claire had given me back the world. And what was I doing now that she needed me?
“Claire, open up.” I jiggled the doorhandle.
Then I heard what it was she was saying. “Sorry. So sorry. I’m just so goddamned sorry.”
“Open up, please, Claire. I want to talk to you.”
“Take my advice. Stay away from all broken people.” I heard her sobbing dryly, almost retching, almost laughing, it became a sort of hum through the door.
I almost said, you’re not broken, you’re just going through something.
But I couldn’t. She knew. There was something terribly wrong with her, all the way inside. She was like a big diamond with a dead spot in the middle. I was supposed to breathe life into that dead spot, but it hadn’t worked.
“Your mother was right,” she said, slurring the words. I heard things crash to the floor. “I am a fool. I can’t even stand myself.” My mother.
Making everything worse.
I sat down on the floor. I felt like an accident victim, holding on to my falling-out insides.
“He’s not coming back, Astrid.” She was right on the other side. Her voice fell from standing height to sitting as she spoke through the crack. “He’s going to divorce me.”
I hoped he would. Then she might have a chance, the two of us, taking it slow, no more Ron coming home, trailing fear, selling hope, leaving her on Christmas, arriving home just when she was getting used to him being gone. It would be fine. No more pretending, holding our breaths, listening in as he talked on the phone. “Claire, you know, it wouldn’t be the worst thing.”
She laughed woozily. “Seventeen years old. Tell me, baby, what is the worst thing?”
was about to say, try having your mother in prison, and the one person you love and trust is going off her rocker. Try being in the best place you ever had and they were talking about sending you back.
But then again, I would not have wanted to be Claire. I would have rather been myself, even my mother, imprisoned for life, full of her own impotent ferocity, than be Claire, worried about burglars and rapists and small teeth mean bad luck and my eyes don’t match and don’t kill the fish and does my husband still love me, did he ever, or did he just think I was someone else, and I can’t pretend anymore.
I wanted to hold her close, but something inside was pushing her away.
This was Claire, who loves you, I reminded myself, but I couldn’t feel it right now. She couldn’t even take care of herself, and I felt myself drifting off. I felt her reaching for my hand, she wanted to come in. I didn’t think I could save her anymore.
“My mother would say the worst thing is losing your self-respect.”
I heard her start to cry again. Sharp, painful hiccups I felt in my own throat. She banged on the door with her fist, or maybe it was her head. I couldn’t stand it, I had to back down into lies.
“Claire, you know he’ll be back. He loves you, don’t worry.” I didn’t care if he came back or not.
“If I knew what self-respect was,” I heard her say, “then maybe I’d know if I’d lost it.”
She had left my portrait on the coffee table. I took it into my room, propped it on the desk. I traced my finger over her high rounded forehead, like a Gothic Madonna.
forehead, like a Gothic Madonna. I went back to her door, knocked.
“Claire, let me in.”
She fumbled with the lock. I opened the door and she fell back into bed, still wearing that red bathrobe.
She pawed her way under the covers like a blind burrowing animal.
“I’m so cold,” she mumbled. “Come in with me.”
I got in, clothes and all. She put her cold feet on mine, her head on my shoulder. The sheets smelled of sherry and dirty hair and L’Air du Temps.
“Stay with me, promise. Don’t leave.”
I held her cold hands, rested my head against hers as she fell asleep. I watched her in the light of the bedside lamp, which was always on now. I told myself, things will turn out all right. Ron would come home or he wouldn’t, and we’d just go on together.
He wouldn’t really send me away. He just didn’t want to see how damaged she was. As long as she didn’t show him, that was all he asked for. A good show.
CLAIRE WAS still sleeping when I woke up. I got up, careful not to disturb her, and went out to the kitchen. I poured myself some cereal. It was very bright, quiet, a pure crystalline light. I was glad Ron was gone. I got my new paints out and painted the way the light looked on the bare wood floor, the yellow tray of sunlight, the way it climbed the curtains. I loved when it was like this. I recalled days just like this when I was young, playing in a patch of sunlight when my mother slept in. A laundry basket over my head, squares of light. I remembered exactly how the sun looked and felt on the back of my hand.
After a while, I checked on Claire.
She had one hand flung across the top of the pillow. Her mouth was open, but she wasn’t snoring now.
“Claire?” I put my face right in hers. She smelled of sherry and something metallic. She didn’t move. I put my hand on her shoulder, shook her gently. “Claire?” She didn’t do anything. The hair stood up on my neck and arms. I couldn’t hear her breathing. “Claire?” I shook her again, but her head flopped like Owen’s giraffe’s. “Claire, wake up.” I lifted her by her shoulders and dropped her. “Claire!” I yelled at her, hoping she would open her eyes, that she would put her hand to her head and tell me not to shout, I was giving her a headache. It was impossible. She was playing a trick, pretending.
I searched the bedside table, the floor. On the far side, I found the pills on the floor, along with the empty sherry bottle. The pill bottle was open, the pills spilled out, small pink tablets. Butalan, the label said.
The sounds I was making were no longer even screams. I wanted to throw something into the fat ugly eye of God. I threw the Kleenex box. The brass bell. I knocked the bedside light off the nightstand. I pulled the magnet box from under the bed and threw it across the room. Ron’s keys and pens and clippers fell out, the Polaroids. For what? I ripped the blinds off the French doors, and the room blinked bright. I took a high-heeled shoe from the foot of the bed and smashed through the windowpanes with it, cut my hand, couldn’t feel it. I took her silver-backed hair-brush and threw it overhand like a baseball into the round mirror. I took the phone and beat the receiver against the headboard until it came apart in my hands, leaving dents in the soft pine.
I was exhausted and couldn’t find anything more to throw. I sat back down on the bed and took her hand. It was so cold. I put it against my hot wet cheek, trying to warm it up, I smoothed her dark hair away from her face.
If only I had known, Claire. My beautiful fucked-up Claire. I lay my head on her chest where there was no heartbeat. My face next to hers on the flowered pillow, breathing in her breath that was no longer breath. She was so pale. Cold. I held her cold hands, slightly chapped, the wedding ring that was too big. Turned them over, kissed the cold palms, my hot lips on the lines. How she used to worry about those lines. One ran from the edge of the hand and crossed the line of life. Fatal accident, she said it meant. I rubbed the line with my thumb, slick with tears.
Fatal accident. That thought was almost unbearable, but possible.
Maybe she hadn’t meant to do it. Claire wouldn’t have planned it like this.
She hadn’t even washed her hair. She would have prepared, everything would have been perfect. She would have written a note, explaining everything two or five ways. Maybe all she wanted was to sleep.
I laughed, bitter as nightshade. Maybe it was just an accident. What
wasn’t an accident. Who wasn’t.
The worst always happened. Why did I keep forgetting that? Now I saw this was not just a bottle, it was a door. You climbed through the round neck of the bottle and came out somewhere else entirely. You could escape. Cash in your chips.
I looked deep into the jar of pink pills. I knew how to do this. You took them slowly. Not like in the movies, where they took them by the handful.
You’d just puke them up. The trick was to take one, wait a few minutes, take the next. Have some sherry. One by one. In a couple of hours, you passed out, and it was done.
I rubbed my cheek against the wool of her robe, the robe Ron got her, she hadn’t taken it off for days. God, I hated that bathrobe, its cheery red plaid. It was always too bright. He never really knew her.
mI had to get rid of that robe before anything. It was the least I could do. I pulled down the covers. I opened the belt and pulled her out of it, how thin she was, how light, her ribs were individually displayed. I laid her back down, careful, careful, I could hardly look at her. Like Christ in her shell-pink underwear. In her dresser I found a soft mauve angora sweater. This was more Claire, the soft color, the plush wool. I put my face into it, hungry for softness, let it soak up my tears. I sat her up. It was hard, I had to lean her against me, overwhelmed by the scent of perfume and her hair. I could hardly breathe, but somehow I pulled the sweater over her head, somehow threaded her arms through, pulled the softness down over her bony shoulder blades. I sat and hugged her, pressing my face to her neck.
I arranged her on the pillow like a princess in a fairy tale, in a glass coffin, a kiss should awaken her. But it didn’t work. I closed her mouth, smoothed the sheets and blankets, found the silver brush in the debris and brushed her hair. I found it comforting, I had done this for her when she was alive. She never even said good-bye. The day my mother left, she didn’t look back either.
I knew I should call Ron. But I didn’t want to share her with him. I wanted her all to myself for just a little while more. When Ron arrived, I would lose Claire for the last time. He didn’t know her, he could bloody well wait.
Claire called me and I didn’t go to her.
Wouldn’t even open my door. I had told her the worst thing was to lose your self-respect. How could I have told her such a thing? Christ, that wasn’t the worst thing, not by a long shot.
In here, the room was steeped in L’Air du Temps from the bottle I’d shattered. I picked up the top, the frosted birds. Now they looked like something to decorate a headstone.
In a drawer, I found the book of pressed flowers she made from the gleanings of our walks on the McKenzie that summer. How happy she’d been in her Chinese hat, tied under the chin, canvas bag full of discoveries.
Here they were, labeled in her round feminine hand, pressed on pages tied together with taupe grosgrain ribbon, Lady’s Slipper, Dogwood, Wild Rose, Rhododendron with their threadlike stamens.
What do you want, Astrid? What do you think? No one would ever ask me that again. I stroked her hair, her dark eyebrows, her eyelids, the delicate formation of cheekbone and eye socket and temple and brow, the sharpness of chin like a drop of water upside down. If only I’d gone to her right away.
If only I hadn’t made her wait. I should never have left her alone with our disgust, Ron’s and mine. It was the one thing she couldn’t stand, to be left alone.
My knee touched hers, recoiled. Her leg was stiff. She was far away now, she was passing through the seven mortal coils, going up to God. I ran my fingers down the pretty, pointed nose, along the smooth forehead, the slight indentation at the temple where no pulse fluttered. She never seemed more complete, more sure of herself. Not trying to please anyone anymore.
She loved me, but she didn’t know me now.
Each time the phone rang, I somehow expected her to jerk awake and answer it. She could never stand not answering the phone. Even when she knew it wouldn’t be for her. It might be a job, though she’d stopped going out on auditions. It might be a friend, though she had no friends. She could get involved in long winding conversations with boiler room operators, Red Carpet Realty, Gold Star Construction.
I couldn’t understand how she could be gone. Who else knew she put mirrors on the roof, or that her favorite movies were Dr. Zhivago and Breakfast at Tiffany’s, that her favorite color was indigo blue? Her lucky number was two. The foods she could never eat were coconut and marzipan.
now.
I sat cross-legged next to her on the bed, counted the pills in the jar. For Insomnia. There were still plenty. More than enough, and the last person who would ever think about me was gone. My mother? She just wanted possession. She thought if she could kill Claire, she would get me back, so she could erase me some more. I felt the pull of that dark circle, the neck of the bottle. It was a rabbit hole, I could jump down it and pull it in after me.
You never knew when help might come.
Now I reaped my despair.
In the end, I didn’t take the pills. It seemed too grandiose, a big gesture, fraudulent. I didn’t deserve to forget that I had turned my back on her.
Oblivion wiped the books clean.
RON SAT NEXT TO ME on the bed, his shoulders sagging like an old horse’s back and his face pressed into his hands, as if he could not look at one more thing. “You were supposed to watch her,” he said.
“You were the one who left.”
He gasped, and broke into long, shuddering sobs. I never thought I would feel sorry for Ron, but I did. I put my hand on his shoulder, and he pressed his hand over mine. It occurred to me I could make him feel better.
I could stroke his hair, and say, It’s not your fault. She had problems we couldn’t have helped, no matter what we did. That’s what Claire would have done. I could have made him love me. Maybe he would keep me.
“I’ve been afraid of this for years.”
He pressed my hand to his cheek. I could feel his tears spill over the back, seeping between my fingers. Claire would have felt sorry for him if she weren’t dead. “I loved her so much,” he said. “I wasn’t a saint, but I loved her. You don’t know.”
I know you did, Ron. Claire would say it. I could feel Olivia too, pressing me. He could take care of me. A man’s world.
But I couldn’t bring myself to do it. Claire was dead. What did it matter if he loved her or not?
I pulled my hand away and got up, started picking up some of the things I’d thrown on the floor. There was his Cross pen. I tossed it in his lap. “She had it all the time,” I said. “You didn’t know her at all.”
He bent his head, touched her dark hair that I had brushed, ran his hand down her mauve angora sleeve. “You can still stay,” he said. “Don’t worry about that.”
I thought it was what I’d wanted to hear. But now that he said it, I knew I’d feel better out on Sunset Boulevard with the other runaways, asleep on a piss quilt on the steps of the homeless church, eating out of the trash at Two Guys from Italy. I couldn’t stay here without Claire.
“Why couldn’t you just have loved her more?” I said.
His hand dropped down. He shook his head. Nobody knew why.
Nobody ever knew why.
IT TOOK LONGER to pack than when I left Amelia’s. There were all the new clothes Claire gave me, the books, the little Dürer rabbit. I took everything. I only had one suitcase, so I packed the rest in shopping bags. It took seven bags to pack it all. I went into the kitchen, reached into the jewelry bag, and took the aquamarine ring that was always too big for her, and her mother too. But it fit me fine.
Ron helped me carry my things out to the van. “I’m sorry,” he said as I climbed in. He fumbled for his wallet, pressed some money on me. Two hundred-dollar bills. My mother would have thrown them in his face, but I took them.
I didn’t give a damn what happened to me now.